UF CLP 41,384.81US dollar CLP 1,008.79Euro CLP 1,107.59
VIVARAE NEWS

COP31 ends without a deal: why the Antalya Pact failed

The Antalya climate summit closed on November 22 without adopting its final decision: the EU, Panama and the Marshall Islands rejected a text that did not mention fossil fuels. What it said, who objected and what happens now.

· Updated · By , journalist

COP31 ends without a deal: why the Antalya Pact failed

Photo: Hendric Stattmann, CC BY-SA 4.0, Wikimedia Commons

COP31 in Antalya, Turkey, ended on Sunday, November 22, without a deal: its president, Turkish minister Murat Kurum, acknowledged at the closing plenary that "there is no consensus" and that the decisions were not adopted, according to Reuters, via Al-Monitor. The European Union, Panama and the Marshall Islands objected to the so-called Antalya Pact, a text that did not mention fossil fuels. It is the biggest breakdown of a UN climate summit since Copenhagen in 2009, according to the same agency.

The summit was due to close on Friday the 20th and the final plenary opened on Sunday more than 40 hours late, according to EFE via Infobae. The failure does not erase what was agreed at earlier summits or the Paris Agreement rules, but it leaves COP31 without a political declaration.

COP31's close in figures
over 40Hours the final plenary ran latescheduled close: Friday 20
98Paragraphs in the final text12 pages
35%2035 electricity targetof final energy use; about 21% today
17Years since the last major breakdownCopenhagen, 2009
View the data as a table
Hours the final plenary ran lateover 40
Paragraphs in the final text98
2035 electricity target35%
Years since the last major breakdown17

Why the Antalya Pact failed

The breaking point was fossil fuels. The fourth draft, published by Turkey and Australia at 3 a.m. on Sunday, did not include the words "fossil", "oil", "coal" or "phase-out", although it referred to the 2023 Dubai agreement on transitioning away from them, according to The Irish Times. Some earlier drafts did mention them. Saudi Arabia, Russia and India opposed any reference, according to the BBC as cited by Inquisitr.

Country or blocPosition at the plenaryWhat it said
European UnionFormal objectionIrish minister Darragh O'Brien, for the EU: a climate pact with no mention of fossil fuels is "unconscionable".
PanamaFormal objectionIt sought a cap on oil production; minister Juan Carlos Navarro said the COP was "hijacked by oil".
Marshall IslandsFormal objectionAnnounced it would also object.
GermanyRejectionMinister Carsten Schneider said he would reject the text as written.
PakistanAsked for more workDid not reject it outright.
Saudi ArabiaDefended the textBacked carbon capture and storage; said the Arab group would remain "constructive".

Sources: Inquisitr, ABC Color and Panamá América. Before the plenary, Turkey and Australia arranged a meeting between the EU and Saudi Arabia that failed to reach a compromise. UN summits decide by consensus, so a few formal objections are enough to block a text.

Oil pumpjacks in a field
The mention of fossil fuels was the issue that split the summit. Photo: Arne Hückelheim, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons.

What the Antalya Pact text said

Although it was not approved, the text shows where the negotiation was heading. According to Down To Earth, which analyzed the Presidency's draft decision published by the UN, and The Irish Times, it included:

TopicWhat it proposedSource
ElectrificationElectricity to reach 35% of final energy use by 2035 ("35 by 35")Down To Earth, Irish Times
Renewables and efficiencyTriple renewable capacity and double the annual efficiency improvement by 2030Down To Earth
AdaptationAt least triple finance by 2035, with no amount or baseline (an earlier draft mentioned US$ 120 billion a year)Down To Earth
Carbon captureGoal of capturing, reusing and storing one billion tonnes of carbonIrish Times
1.5 °CAcknowledged for the first time that warming is on course to exceed 1.5 °CReuters
Fossil fuelsNo direct mention; only a reference to the 2023 Dubai agreementIrish Times

Sources differ on the starting point of the electricity target: The Irish Times says about 21% of final energy use today, while Türkiye Today mentions 22% and other reports 23%. Turkey, which pushed the target, gathered the support of about 75 countries, according to the same Turkish outlet.

The electricity target the Antalya Pact proposedElectricity's share of global final energy use, %
The current figure ranges from 21% to 23% depending on the source.Source: The Irish Times; Down To Earth.
View the data as a table
Today (approx.)21%
2035 target35%
Wind turbines and solar panels at a park
Turkey's electrification target did not require the electricity to be renewable only, one of activists' criticisms. Photo: Geographer, CC BY-SA 2.0, Wikimedia Commons.

What Latin America sought at COP31

Panama was the toughest Latin American country. Before the close, its environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, sent a letter to the Presidency warning that he would not approve any resolution without a commitment to cap global oil production at current levels, an acknowledgment that the 1.5 °C goal is not being met and more climate finance, according to Panamá América. It also demanded that the 35% electrification target for 2035 be met with clean energy, according to ABC Color.

Panama's demandWhat the final text said
Cap on oil production at current levelsNo mention of fossil fuels
Acknowledge the 1.5 °C goal is not being metAcknowledged warming is on course to exceed 1.5 °C
More adaptation financeTriple by 2035, with no amount or baseline
Electrification with clean energy35% target without requiring it to be renewable

Sources: Panamá América, ABC Color, Down To Earth and Reuters, via Al-Monitor. Panama, together with Vanuatu, Tuvalu and Fiji, is also pushing a treaty to coordinate reductions in coal, oil and gas production, since the Paris Agreement sets no limits on fuel supply. At the time of writing, the final positions of Brazil, Mexico, Colombia and Chile at the plenary were not known.

How COP31 reached its breakdown

COP31's two weeks in Antalya
  1. Nov 9OpeningTurkey presides and Australia leads the negotiations.
  2. Nov 16First draft144 paragraphs.
  3. Nov 19Revised draftAccording to Down To Earth, it omits the transition away from fossil fuels and keeps "35 by 35".
  4. Nov 20Scheduled closeNo deal; overtime begins.
  5. Nov 22, 3:00Fourth draftAntalya Pact, without the word "fossil".
  6. Nov 22Not adoptedEU, Panama and the Marshall Islands object; Kurum acknowledges there is no consensus.

What happens now after COP31 without a deal

  • Pending items move to the next summit: under rule 16 of the rules of procedure, unresolved business passes to the next session, according to Inquisitr.
  • COP32 will be held in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, in 2027, after the African Group's endorsement (Wikipedia).
  • Earlier agreements still stand: obligations under the Paris Agreement and previous summits are not cancelled, according to Reuters, via Al-Monitor.
  • Latin America was split: Panama led the toughest line against oil. What the region brought is in what was negotiated at COP31 and what Latin American countries brought.

Frequently asked questions

Was there a deal at COP31?

No. On November 22 the Presidency acknowledged there was no consensus and the Antalya Pact was not adopted.

Who rejected the Antalya Pact?

The European Union, Panama and the Marshall Islands lodged formal objections; Germany announced its rejection.

What is the 35 by 35 target?

Turkey's proposal that electricity reach 35% of the world's final energy use by 2035.

Where will COP32 be held?

In Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, in 2027.