UF CLP 41,371.05US dollar CLP 1,008.79Euro CLP 1,107.59
VIVARAE NEWS

Argentina's Supreme Court halts prepaid health plan price deregulation: what changes for members

Argentina's Supreme Court struck down articles 267 and 269 of Decree 70/2023: prepaid health plans again need approval from the Superintendency of Health Services to raise fees. It sets no inflation cap and no automatic refunds. The case, the figures and what members can do.

· Updated · By , journalist

Argentina's Supreme Court halts prepaid health plan price deregulation: what changes for members

Photo: GameOfLight, CC BY-SA 3.0, Wikimedia Commons

Argentina's Supreme Court of Justice struck down articles 267 and 269 of DNU 70/2023, which since December 2023 had let prepaid health companies set their fees freely. The ruling, signed on November 19, 2026 by Justices Horacio Rosatti, Carlos Rosenkrantz and Ricardo Lorenzetti, returns to the Superintendency of Health Services the power to review and authorize every increase, according to Infobae and El Tribuno. It is the first time the Court has declared part of Javier Milei's mega-decree unconstitutional.

The ruling does not freeze fees, set a cap or order refunds. In fact, the Court overturned the part of the La Plata Federal Appeals Court decision that limited increases to inflation. What changes is the procedure: prepaid plans will have to justify each increase with their cost structure and a reasonable actuarial calculation before applying it.

The Court's prepaid health ruling in figures
110%Increase in the plaintiff's feeDec 2023 to Feb 2024, per the lawsuit
6.26%Increase under the previous rulesJanuary 2024, Res. 2577/2022
500Similar cases pending at the Courtabout 500
2Decree articles struck down267 and 269
View the data as a table
Increase in the plaintiff's fee110%
Increase under the previous rules6.26%
Similar cases pending at the Court500
Decree articles struck down2

What the Supreme Court said about prepaid health plans

The case is "Bobbio, María del Carmen v. Swiss Medical S.A. and another, amparo under Law 16,986". The member, on an SM02 plan, sued because her fee went from ARS 136,161.21 in December 2023 to ARS 301,218.02 in February 2024. According to her filing, had Health Ministry Resolution 2577/2022 been applied, the January 2024 adjustment would have been 6.26%. It reached the Court on appeals by the company and the national government.

The plaintiff's SM02 plan fee, in pesos
Source: Lawsuit figures cited by El Tribuno.
View the data as a table
December 2023$136,161 · $136.161,21
February 2024$301,218 · $301.218,02

Media cite a 110% increase; using the amounts in the lawsuit, the difference between December and February is 121%. Over the same period, inflation measured by INDEC was 25.5% in December 2023, 20.6% in January and 13.2% in February 2024, about 71% cumulative.

The central argument was about the instrument, not prices. The Court recalled that a decree of necessity and urgency is valid only when Congress cannot legislate through the ordinary process or when urgency demands an immediate solution, the doctrine it reaffirmed in the "Cencosud" case on August 13. According to Infobae, the court found that citing a "health system crisis" and the need to "increase competitiveness" did not prove such urgency. It also clarified that it expresses no view on the rest of Decree 70/2023.

Façade of the British Hospital in Buenos Aires
Prepaid plans will have to justify increases with their cost structure. Photo: Hospital Británico, CC BY 3.0, Wikimedia Commons.

What changes for prepaid health plan members

IssueUnder Decree 70/2023 (Dec 2023 to Nov 2026)After the Court ruling
Who sets the feeThe company, freelyThe company proposes and the Superintendency authorizes
Prior state controlNoYes, based on costs and actuarial calculation
Inflation (CPI) capNoNo: the Court overturned that cap
Refund of amounts chargedNot applicableNot automatic; each member must claim
FreezeNoNo

Sources: Infobae, El Tribuno and Urgente24. The rule back in force is Law 26,682, the 2011 regulatory framework for prepaid health. The ruling decides the specific case but sets a standard for about 500 similar cases pending at the Court and for injunctions in lower courts.

From the prepaid health law to the Court ruling
  1. 2011Law 26,682Regulatory framework: the state authorizes increases.
  2. Dec 21, 2023Decree 70/2023 publishedFrees prepaid health prices.
  3. Dec 2023 to Feb 2024The plaintiff's fee rises 110%
  4. Aug 13, 2026Cencosud caseThe Court reaffirms limits on decrees.
  5. Nov 19, 2026Bobbio v. Swiss Medical rulingArticles 267 and 269 unconstitutional.

Who is who in the prepaid health case

PartyRole in the case
María del Carmen BobbioSM02 plan member who filed the amparo
Swiss Medical S.A.Prepaid health company sued; appealed to the Court
National governmentDefended Decree 70/2023; also appealed
La Plata Federal Appeals CourtRuled for the member and set a CPI cap, which the Court overturned
Supreme Court (Rosatti, Rosenkrantz and Lorenzetti)Partly upheld and struck down articles 267 and 269
Superintendency of Health ServicesRegains the power to authorize increases
Argentine Health Union (UAS)Industry chamber; criticized the ruling

Sources: Infobae and El Tribuno. An amparo is the fast-track action under Law 16,986 to stop acts that violate constitutional rights, which is why an individual case could reach the Court. A DNU, by contrast, is a rule issued by the President with the force of law in exceptional situations, which Congress can reject. Decree 70/2023 amended or repealed hundreds of rules, including Law 26,682, which since 2011 had required prepaid plans to seek approval to change their prices.

What prepaid health plan members can do

  • Check the next increase: from now on, each increase should have the Superintendency of Health Services' approval. It is worth asking the company for the resolution number or proof of authorization.
  • Claims for amounts paid: refunds are not automatic. Those who want to recover part of what they paid since 2024 must file a complaint with the Superintendency or go to court, with legal advice.
  • Keep the invoices: month-by-month fees since December 2023 are the key evidence in any claim.
Sanatorio de los Arcos in Buenos Aires
Swiss Medical, the company sued in the case, is one of the country's largest prepaid health providers. Photo: Travis Alber, CC BY 2.0, Wikimedia Commons.

The prepaid health industry's reaction and what comes next

Hugo Magonza, president of the Argentine Health Union (UAS), which groups prepaid plans, said the ruling creates "an enormous level of legal uncertainty" and warned that "people are going to be left without coverage", according to El Tribuno. The government had not taken an official position at the time of writing. It remains to be seen how the Superintendency will apply the control: with what formula, how often and whether it will review upcoming increases.

Monthly inflation in Argentina when prepaid plans were freed and today
Source: INDEC.
View the data as a table
Dec 202325.5%
Jan 202420.6%
Feb 202413.2%
Oct 20262.2%
MonthMonthly inflation (INDEC)
December 202325.5%
January 202420.6%
February 202413.2%
Three-month cumulative71.4%
October 20262.2%

Source: INDEC, consumer price index (official series on datos.gob.ar); cumulative figure calculated by Vivarae News. With monthly inflation now far below 2024 levels, the debate is about how much room fees will have to track medical costs. For economic context, see Argentina's October inflation, November pensions and health spending in Latin America. The president's profile is in who Javier Milei is.

Frequently asked questions

What did the Supreme Court decide on prepaid health plans?

It struck down articles 267 and 269 of Decree 70/2023 and returned to the Superintendency of Health Services the power to authorize fee increases.

Do fees go down or freeze?

No. The ruling sets no freeze, cap or cut; it requires each increase to be authorized based on costs.

Will I get back what I overpaid?

Not automatically. The Court did not order general refunds; each member would have to make a claim.

Does all of Decree 70/2023 fall?

No. The Court said its decision is limited to articles 267 and 269 and expresses no view on the rest of the decree.